Why We Believe in Campaign Promises Against Better Judgment

The Paradox of Hope

In August 2022, Kenya’s President William Ruto stood before a crowd in Nairobi’s Kamukunji grounds, railing against the “elite cartels” suffocating ordinary citizens. His campaign mantra, “Kazi kwa Wote” (Jobs for All), promised to uplift millions of unemployed youth through a “hustler fund” and slash the cost of living. Fast-forward to 2024: inflation hovers at 6.8%, youth unemployment remains stubbornly high at 13% (KNBS, 2023), and the hustler fund has disbursed just 15% of its target (Central Bank of Kenya, 2023). Yet, as Kenya gears up for another election cycle, voters are again listening intently to grandiose pledges. This paradox—believing in promises we know are unlikely to materialize—is not unique to Kenya. From Brazil’s Lula to India’s Modi, voters globally cling to political narratives that defy empirical scrutiny.

Why?

I. The Psychology of Hope: Why Rationality Loses to EmotionCognitive Dissonance and the “Maybe This Time” SyndromeHumans are wired to resolve contradictions between belief and reality. Cognitive dissonance theory explains why Kenyans, despite witnessing decades of unfulfilled promises, suppress skepticism. A 2023 Afrobarometer survey found that 62% of Kenyans distrust politicians, yet 58% still vote based on pledges (Afrobarometer, 2023). This dissonance is soothed by hope—the belief that this leader, this time, will be different.

Social Identity and Tribal AffinityIn Kenya’s ethnically charged politics, promises are secondary to tribal allegiance. Ruto’s 2022 victory was bolstered by the “Hustler vs. Dynasty” narrative, which tapped into deep-seated class and ethnic loyalties. As political scientist Mutahi Ngunyi notes, “In Kenya, you don’t vote with your head; you vote with your stomach and your tribe.”

II. Structural Realities: Systems That Enable Empty PromisesWeak Institutions and Accountability GapsKenya’s institutions, from Parliament to anti-corruption bodies, often lack the teeth to hold leaders accountable. Despite the 2010 Constitution’s devolution framework, only 12% of county governments audited in 2023 received clean bills of health (Auditor General’s Report, 2023). This impunity emboldens politicians to overpromise.

Patronage Politics: The “Carrot-and-Stick” EconomyCampaigns in Kenya are less about policy than patronage. A 2023 report by Transparency International revealed that 43% of voters received bribes (often as little as $5) during the 2022 elections. Such transactional politics prioritize short-term handouts over long-term pledges.

Economic Desperation: “Anything is Better Than This”With 36% of Kenyans living below the poverty line (World Bank, 2023), even implausible promises—like Ruto’s pledge to create 1.2 million jobs annually—resonate. As economist David Ndii argues, “When you’re desperate, you’ll grasp at any lifeline, even if it’s made of smoke.”

III. Global Parallels: Broken Promises as a Universal Political CurrencyUnited States: Biden’s Student Loan Forgiveness DilemmaIn 2020, Biden promised to cancel $10,000 in student debt. By 2023, the Supreme Court had blocked the plan, yet 48% of young voters still approved of his handling of education (Pew Research, 2023). The promise, though unfulfilled, solidified loyalty among key demographics.

India: Modi’s Jobs MiragePrime Minister Narendra Modi’s 2019 pledge to create 20 million annual jobs collided with a 7.9% unemployment rate in 2023 (Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy). Yet, his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) retains a 39% approval rating on economic issues, underscoring the power of nationalist rhetoric over material outcomes.

Brazil: Lula’s Amazon Balancing ActPresident Lula’s 2022 vow to end Amazon deforestation clashed with economic pressures to exploit resources. While deforestation dropped by 50% in 2023 (IMAZON), mining concessions rose by 30%, leaving voters torn between environmental hopes and economic realities.

IV. The Cost of Cynicism: Democracy’s Dangerous SlideRepeated betrayal breeds apathy. Kenya’s 2022 voter turnout (65%) marked a 10% drop from 2017, reflecting growing disillusionment (IEBC). Globally, only 47% of people in 64 countries trust elections (Gallup, 2023). Yet, disengagement empowers populists who exploit grievances, creating a vicious cycle of hope and disillusionment.

V. Pathways to Accountability: Rebuilding TrustStrengthening InstitutionsKenya’s proposed Office of the Public Interest Ombudsman (PIO, 2023) could mandate quarterly progress reports on campaign pledges, enforceable via courts. Ghana’s 2016 “Manifesto Tracking” initiative offers a blueprint, with civil society groups monitoring government promises.

Civic Education and Critical ThinkingInitiatives like Kenya’s “Ugatuzi Hub,” which uses data visualization to track county budgets, empower voters to demand transparency. In India, the “Satark Nagrik Sangathan” NGO rates MPs on promise fulfillment, combining humor and hard data to engage youth.

Conclusion: The Delicate Dance of DemocracyThe allure of campaign promises lies in their simplicity: they offer a vision of a better world. Yet, as Kenya and nations worldwide show, the gap between promise and reality is often a chasm. Closing it requires not just better leaders, but better systems—and citizens equipped to separate hope from hubris.

Sources: